… by Anna Quindlen. Published in 1994, one of many she has produced over a lifetime of prolific writing, including non-fiction and books specifically for children. Several of her books have been optioned for screenplays, and she continues to write and publish. Recently reviewed here, “More Than Enough”, well-written and the reason to search for more of her work.
Ellen, living in New York City, returns to her parent’s home when she is told her mother has been diagnosed with cancer. Knowing her parents will need support, but never fully realizing the extent to which the parents are both ready to fully turn over their lives to her ministrations – she becomes the care-giver, nurse, mother, cook, housekeeper, maid, laundry person for both her mom and dad. Her dad continues to work full time in academia in a small college as an English professor, seemingly unwilling to take responsibility, be involved in the care of his wife.
The community where Ellen grew up, her parents still live, seems unable to accept the change brought about by the medical diagnosis, and gives this struggling young woman little support as she attempts to manage her parents’ lives and household. Though her mother was valued by friends, the women seem to hold the family at arm’s length as Ellen attempts to help hold the family together. A hospice/respite worker Teresa, becomes a close friend and confidante, providing Ellen with support, advice, and assisting her mother with pain management.
When her mother dies, Ellen is accused of overdosing, in effect killing her mother with a massive dose of morphine. The grand jury chooses to not indict, but with so much publicity, Ellen feels condemned by the media in the insular community where she grew up. If the grand jury had chosen to do so, she could have been tried for murder. Although convinced her dad provided the drugs and fed the pain killer to his wife, she does not share this information. Her father never speaks to her again. Ellen is taken in by a former high-school teacher/mentor, where she stays until returning to the city. The way the book is written – it’s hard to ascertain who is responsible for the death: Ellen, her father, or possibly her mother in a brief moment of lucidity.

The book was beautifully written. Conversations between characters were thoughtful, believable, seemed to bring the family to life. As Ellen and her parents, siblings, community members interacted, they seemed to interact in ways families do, discussing tivial, mundane bits and pieces of their lives.



















